Supreme Court Had the Chance to Overrule Thryv Remedies, but Didn’t

The NLRB’s 2022 Thryv decision rewrote what “make-whole” means. It’s not only lost wages anymore. It’s every direct and foreseeable financial harm an employee suffers from the violation — out-of-pocket medical costs after a health plan lapses, credit card interest, late fees, a repossessed car, new suit for a job interview. The kind of consequential damages that used to live in civil court now show up on an NLRB remedy.

Employers pushed back hard, and the circuits split. The Ninth Circuit upheld the remedy this year in Macy’s (it’s the only one to do so). The Third, Fifth, and Sixth Circuits rejected Thryv remedies as beyond the Board’s authority. The Supreme Court denied cert and walked away from the fight entirely.

Board law doesn’t change when a court of appeals rules against it. Under its nonacquiescence policy, Thryv stays fully binding until the Supreme Court or the Board itself overrules it.

Only if your case lands in the Third, Fifth, or Sixth Circuit, can you assume traditional backpay remedies, only. If you’re in the Ninth Circuit, expect Thryv remedies. If you’re in another Circuit, follow the lead arguments in the Circuits that have already denounced Thryv and hope your Circuit does, too.

Do you think SCOTUS is letting the soon-to-be Trump NLRB overturn Thryv on its own?

For more, subscribe to my newsletter: https://lnkd.in/gEZXXmeC