Your Next Union Campaign May Arrive Through Your Shareholders
Private-sector union density is 5.9%. Capital strategy is how unions punch well above that number.
Jarrett Skorup of the Mackinac Center for Public Policy made the argument: as membership shrinks, unions increasingly work through pension fund ESG investing to move corporate behavior. He contends the tactic buys influence far out of proportion to actual membership, that it hurts union members in energy-dependent industries, and that it strains the fiduciary duty pension trustees owe their beneficiaries. His fix is federal and state reform of fiduciary standards.
The membership numbers hold up. BLS put union density at 10.0% overall in 2025 — 5.9% in the private sector, 32.9% in government.
Private-sector density is has been in a freefall for years (decades?). Public-sector density is more than five times higher. And the public sector is where the enormous pension funds live.
The mechanics are simple enough. A corporate campaign doesn’t have to start at your loading dock. Union-affiliated and public pension funds own shares. Shareholder proposals, proxy voting, board engagement, and ESG frameworks all become channels — and one of the asks that travels through those channels is a neutrality agreement.
That’s the moment it stops being a governance question and becomes a labor relations one.
Understand what a neutrality agreement actually is. It’s a contract. Depending on the terms, it can waive your ability to communicate with your own employees during an organizing campaign, grant organizers access to your property, hand over employee names and contact information, and commit you to card check recognition instead of a secret ballot election. Companies that enter neutrality agreements end up with a union about 89% of the time.
Every one of those is a right employers have gone to federal court to protect. And this version gets signed in a conference room, by people who may never have spoken to a labor lawyer, as one line item in a shareholder engagement package.
For employers: whoever handles your investor relations needs to know what a neutrality commitment costs before they agree to one.
Somewhere out there is a board deck with a neutrality commitment sitting on slide 40, and no labor counsel has laid eyes on it. I think Jarrett Skorup is on to something.
For more like this, please subscribe to my newsletter The Labor Leader: https://lnkd.in/gMzA2V-n
For a weekly recap of all NLRB publications, please subscribe to my newsletter NLRB Publications Weekly: https://lnkd.in/gJ2gaM9P