A “Republican” Labor Board Is Not an Automatic Win for Employers
I’ve said this before, if you’re an employer counting on the new NLRB to rubber-stamp your election objections, this one’s a wake-up call.
The Board refused to review DaVita’s challenge to an SEIU win at its Vallejo, California dialysis clinic. The company had a legitimate argument: it claimed the union illegally videotaped workers at an anti-union protest during the critical pre-election window and spread the footage around. This is serious. Surveillance objections can flip an election.
But the NLRB majority found otherwise. DaVita, they said, did not put forward enough evidence to make even a prima facie case. No hearing. Certification stands.
The vote that sank DaVita came from Republican Chair James Murphy joining the Board’s lone Democrat — over the dissent of fellow Republican Scott Mayer, who said the surveillance claim raised “substantial and material issues” that deserved a hearing.
The lesson for employers: party labels don’t win cases. Evidence does.
For more like this, please subscribe to my newsletter: https://lnkd.in/gEZXXmeC