In a Union Election, a Tie Goes to the Employer
Two ballots cost Starbucks Workers United a café.
The NLRB ruled that two votes in a Seattle mail-in election never should have counted — because the workers hand-delivered them to the regional office instead of mailing them in. Agency rules don’t allow that, the Board’s majority held. Toss the two ballots, and the election stays deadlocked at 4-4.
And a deadlock is a loss for the union. To win representation, a union needs a majority — not a tie. No majority, no certification. Starbucks wins.
The Board’s lone Democrat, David Prouty, dissented, arguing nothing in the rules expressly bans hand delivery and it doesn’t hurt election integrity. The Republican majority disagreed, and their reading of the rulebook decided it.
The takeaway for employers: Procedure is substance. Knowing exactly how ballots may be cast, delivered, and counted can be the difference between a union representing your employees and business as usual.
For more like this, please subscribe to my newsletter: https://lnkd.in/ghrn7drk