One in Five Workers Stays Quiet About Safety Because They’re Afraid of Management

Employees choose unions when they don’t feel heard, respected, or safe at work. This is low-hanging fruit for union organizing.

TRADESAFE surveyed 503 blue-collar workers across multiple industries, reported by EHS Today on July 29. The numbers on why people don’t speak up should stop you cold.

36% didn’t believe anything would change. 20% feared retaliation from management. 17% weren’t sure the hazard was serious enough. 12% pointed to peer pressure.

32% said speaking up could hurt their job security, promotions, or reputation. Among workers who didn’t feel safe raising concerns, 51% stayed silent — against 20% of workers who did feel safe. And 25% watched a near-miss go unreported.

Then there’s enforcement. 38% have seen safety violations go undisciplined. Logistics was worst at 54%, then manufacturing at 45%, healthcare at 39%, construction at 35%.

Ask who gets protected from discipline and the answers get uncomfortable. A close relationship with a supervisor: 39%. Seniority: 36%. High productivity: 19%. Job title: 19%. Union membership: 13%. Being friendly with your supervisor protects you three times better than being in the union. Go figure.

Here’s why this labor lawyer cares about a safety survey.

Safety complaints sit on top of two separate statutes. OSHA’s Section 11(c) prohibits retaliation against employees who raise safety concerns, though the employee has only 30 days to file. And Section 7 of the National Labor Relations Act protects employees who act together over working conditions — safety very much included — whether or not a union exists anywhere on the property. Two employees jointly raising a hazard is concerted activity. Discipline them for it and you have an 8(a)(1), with no union in sight.

So that 20% who stay quiet out of fear aren’t describing a feeling. They’re describing what they watched happen to somebody else.

One more number, and it’s the one that should worry non-union employers most. Non-union workers reported unpunished violations more often than union workers — 44% versus 36%.

For employers: inconsistent enforcement isn’t only a safety failure. It is the single best piece of campaign literature you can hand an organizer, and you’ll have written it yourself.

For more like this, please subscribe to my newsletter The Labor Leader: https://lnkd.in/gMzA2V-n

For a weekly recap of all NLRB publications, please subscribe to my newsletter NLRB Publications Weekly: https://lnkd.in/gJ2gaM9P